-1.png)
HR investigations examine allegations of wrongdoing or misconduct in the workplace, including harassment, discrimination, safeguarding, or any other behaviour that violates company policies, procedures, or legal regulations. These investigations are crucial to maintaining a safe and respectful workplace environment for everyone.
In all instances, an HR investigation should be conducted promptly and impartially. This means launching an investigation as soon as a potential allegation is highlighted and treating all involved parties fairly. Organisations must ensure the investigation is completed in a timely manner and all evidence is thoroughly reviewed. Due to the sensitive nature of such cases, we see many schools outsourcing for support to maintain their impartiality throughout.
Importance of conducting an HR investigation
HR investigations are an essential part of maintaining a healthy workplace culture. When concerns are not addressed and investigated it can create an unhealthy work environment leading to low morale, high turnover, and legal consequences. In other cases, failing to address complaints can bring schools or trusts into serious disrepute.
Conducting an HR investigation demonstrates the organisation's commitment to maintaining a respectful and safe workplace. They help identify and address problematic behaviours, leading to a positive workplace culture and giving employees the confidence to speak up if they witness or experience misconduct.
Preparing for an investigation
Thorough preparation is essential before launching an investigation, so the Investigating Officer must ensure they have the tools and resources to conduct this fairly and impartially. This includes reviewing the company's policies and procedures, determining the scope of the investigation, identifying potential witnesses, and any supporting evidence.
Selecting an impartial investigator with the necessary investigative skills is also crucial, whether this is an individual from another department or an external consultant. Organisations need to be sure that the selected investigator has the necessary experience to conduct an investigation effectively.
Alongside this, an employee has the right to robust communication and they must be kept up to date with timelines and any potential delays. The Investigator also needs to understand the legal rights for the employee and ensure this is adhered to so that appeals and potential legal claims are avoided.
Conducting interviews during an HR investigation
One of the most critical aspects of an HR investigation is conducting interviews with witnesses and the parties involved. Investigating Officers must ensure that they are asking the right questions and gathering all relevant information, while maintaining confidentiality, so that all parties are treated with respect and fairness.
To capture all relevant information during interviews, Investigating Officers need to ask open-ended questions, listen carefully, and take detailed notes. It's also important to be aware of nonverbal cues and body language, which can provide additional insights into the situation.
After conducting interviews, Investigating Officers must carefully review all evidence and determine the credibility of each witness; there must be no bias or prejudice in their analysis.
Documenting the HR investigation process
Thoroughly documenting the investigation process and providing regular updates to all parties is also crucial.
Investigating Officers must ensure that all evidence is collected, reviewed, and analysed. This requires maintaining accurate and detailed records of the investigation, including notes from interviews, emails, and other relevant documentation. This documentation should demonstrate that the investigation was conducted fairly and impartially and can be used as evidence if legal action is taken.
Common mistakes to avoid during a disciplinary investigation
HR investigations can be complex and challenging, but there are several common mistakes that Investigating Officers should avoid:
- failing to conduct a thorough investigation
Investigating Officers must review all evidence and interview all relevant parties. - failing to maintain confidentiality
Investigating Officers must ensure that all parties involved understand the confidentiality requirements and that they are not sharing information with anyone who is not directly involved in the investigation.
- failing to comply with all relevant laws and regulations
Investigating Officers must comply with these laws; failure to do so can lead to legal consequences and damage the organisation’s reputation
- failing to conduct an investigation soon enough or rushing the process
Investigating Officers should aim to conclude their investigation as swiftly as possible whilst ensuring they have allowed time for a thorough investigation to take place. - seeking evidence to confirm guilt and failing to consider exculpatory evidence
Investigating Officers should focus on seeking the facts of the matter being investigated and consider all evidence.
- producing an inadequate investigation report
Investigating Officers should ensure their investigation report covers all allegations and highlights the key evidence considered when reaching their conclusions.
Handling disciplinary investigation outcomes
After completing an HR investigation, the appropriate course of action must be determined. The Investigating Officer should submit their report to the commissioning officer who will determine the next steps. This could be no further action, an informal outcome or to convene a disciplinary hearing.
Conclusion
HR investigations are essential to maintain a safe and respectful workplace environment. Investigating Officers must ensure that they conduct investigations fairly and impartially and comply with all relevant laws and regulations. They must communicate effectively and maintain confidentiality throughout the process.
By following these best practices, Investigating Officers can conduct successful investigations that promote a positive workplace culture and protect the organisation's reputation.
